This would be our first trip to the Caribbean (unless you count Cancun, Isla Mujeres, and Playa del Carmen, Mexico. I don't know if that is technically considered the Caribbean or not). If you had to choose 1 Caribbean island, which one would it be and why? We would be looking for calm water, great beach, nice snorkeling, and a relaxing get away. We have considered a cruise (which would be our first one also), but I think staying in 1 location would be nice too. Any thoughts????