I have no idea how to figure out which of the many Caribbean Islands we should go to for a week-and-a-half stay in mid-October.
St. Kitts has made the short list (although it's still kind of a long list).
How does it rank compared to:
We are mid-twenties, not much for night life though... enjoy great snorkeling, beach, boogey boarding/surfing, shopping, low-crime type of island. We've gone to Hawaii the past two years and have loved it, but want to try something a little closer to home. Any advice would be appreciated.