Just got home from 8 days at the Majestic Elegance for our Honeymoon. We had a great time there overall. There are huge variations in service. When we arrived our butler was Henry, who was amazing. Everything night we came back to the room to a bottle of wine or champagne and a plate of something. He unfortunately left and we were stuck with Olvideo who did absolutely nothing for us, nor did we see him at all. No biggie really, but other couples we met who had him got no service like we did from Henry. We noticed little things like this when speaking to other honeymooners in the club section. We recieved a 1/5 of baileys a few nights into our trip, but others did not. We received two shirts upon arrival, but no hats. Others got hats and no shirts. Some got hats and shirts. Food was good overall, no complaints really there. Beach is beautiful. Since it was our honeymoon, I think the club section did give us some perks due to henry being our butler, but if I were to go back again, which I wouldn't, the club section gives you nothing more than any other section. You get a sit down breakfast with very little on the menu and a sit down lunch, but who wants to walk all the way back to the italian from the beach and have to change. Unless the private pool is a necessity to you, save you money and stay in the regular section. Bartenders were all top notch and friendly.
I do want to say that take the ratings of the Colonial and Elegance with a grain of salt. We recieved slips of papers from workers with tripadvisors web address and their name to leave reviews. This will obviously draw people to trip advisor who normally would not and in turn inflate the ratings. It was a great time, but would return to the Palladium Royal Suites again before coming back here. Another couple said the same thing. If you want adults only, you will not get it here since you are all intermingled. Royal Suites is cheaper and a superior resort IMHO.
Please feel free to ask any questions and I will do my best to respond.