My husband and I, married 23 years, are planning to take our first Sandals Jamaica vacation and I'm torn which resort. We have it narrowed down to Ochos Rios Riviera, Negril or Royal Carribean. I don't mind the distance from the airports. We're looking for a nice combination of relaxation and activity. I love the idea of the exclusive island at Royal Carribean, I've heard great things about Riviera but am concerned about the small beach and Negril sounds like more beach but maybe a bit outdated and hard to get chairs and water floaties without butler service. Actually, I'm wondering if not having butler service at any of these puts you at a disadvantage for beach/pool chairs and dinner tables. Any feedback on these three resorts would be great!