This is not our first trip to JA but have not stayed at any of the places mentioned. Blue Cave Castle has been home to us and we love it! This time though we are looking for a bit more with a bit more to spend- looking for a bar, pool, AC. Planning a trip for 10 nights. We do want something private. Preferably right on the water with its own sea access. I have visited a few of the places personally and looked on line for info.
What I am hoping is that some of you who have stayed at these places might have some suggestions on which rooms/villas you might recommend for privacy, AC and that water access.