We will visit Grand Cayman in January of 2014 and have been looking at renting a car from Budget. The question is why is the rate so different (much cheaper) when I go to reserve a Toyota Yaris on the generic budget,com site from the rate ($135 more) when trying to reserve the exact same car on the budgetcayman.com site. Are the two not the same company? And it looks like the budgetcayman.com site has a bunch more recommended adders for third party liability insurance @ $11/day, personal accident protection @ $3/day (supposed to be "out of their own pocket"???), road side safety net @ $3/day $20/week, a total of $17/day extra without the collision damage waiver ($20/day) which my Amex credit card will cover for the one time $24 fee. Is Budget on Cayman unique with all these charges or do all the rent-a-car places there charge these fees?
Any advice regarding car rental in general on Grand Cayman would be greatly appreciated.