We haven't been to either destination and would love to hear some recommendations. Last few trips have been to Aruba because of the amazing restaurants and beautiful beaches. We always rent a car and are up to explore the entire island. We don't mind being in the "action" as long as it is not extremely crowded and miserable. We will be traveling with our little one (2 years old). Sticking with Marriott properties because we are using points.
Thanks in advance for your thoughts!