My good friend and I went last may and visited my cousin in st thomas. We stayed at her place which is cramped for 4 people (including her husband) but nice. After a couple days we stayed at maho on st john for a few days which i loved loved. St john is beautiful and so peaceful. We did cruz bay went to coral bay didnt go to all restaurants i wanted to but ill go this time. La tapas is amazing so ill go there again and i also enjoyed high tide right on the water by the ferry dock. We ended back on st thomas at my cousins friends house on mandahl bay which was awesome. In total it was 8 days...it wasnt enough. So this time we are going 11 days. How should we split our time? If you read this far haha...we wanna do bvi. Can we stay there? We arent rich...but...im going to try and save. We will do maho because i liked it and its cheap. We will also rent a car because taxis add up. And i know the islands now. Should we rent on st thomas and take on ferry? I know not all rent to go to st john. Id like any inexpensive villa suggestions that rent for less than a week. More than 200 a night is pushing it. Just something nicer than a cabin i guess. We are adventurous. Ill be 28. Im a male. My friend is female young 40s both active..also considering a dinghy rental in addition to one catamaran trip. Did daydreamer last may was awesome. Any other suggestions for second time friends Would be appreciated! Nate..sorry for rambling.