I know this topic has been adressed before, but I am still undecided...
My husband and I are planning a trip (without our children!) for January 2009. We are in our early 40's, he loves to golf, and I love serene, beautiful beaches. I also like to walk/run, and be active. We are casual people and like to eat in laid back places. Also enjoy some sort of beachside or poolside bar for afternoon cocktails. Not big on nightlife. Feeling safe is a big deal, as we often do our own thing in the morning hours. We have been to Aruba many times, and Jamaica (Half Moon, Montego Bay) once. Love Aruba, but it is very American, and loved Half Moon, but did not like Montego Bay for the crime and poverty.
So...Buccaneer vs. Carambola? either way we will rent a car and do some adventuring offsite. Better beaches at one vs. the other? Better golf?
Any suggestions or insight are welcomed!