Okay I am overwhelmed with our choices of activities to choose from. I already know we are going to have to return to St. Thomas as we will not be able to do all the activities in our short stay. We are staying at the Sugar Bay Resort (all inclusive) so the only restaurant recommendation is for our day trip. (Please no negitive comments on our all inclusive choice, thank you!) We take 3 5 night vacations a year and allow ourselves 2 excursion a trip consisting of a snorkeling/sail (all day), shopping and an island tour (which sometimes we incorperate shopping with the island tour. I would love to do a sail trip to the Baths but would love to snorkel in St. Johns or with the turtles. Please give me some feed back to help us choose. Thank You we are arriving May 16th and departing May 21st.