My husband and I are coming back to StJ in July and bringing his parents along with us(their first time). We stayed in Astral Ridge in Coral Bay the first time, and this time we will be in Beit Haiwa near Cruz Bay. Our favorite lunch spot the first time around was Aqua Bistro, but now we will be on the other side of the island and don't know where to go.
I've seen many posts asking about the best restaurants (Asolare, Tapas, etc), but we are more interested in the casual, no-reservations, "off the beaten path", under 15$pp kinda place that has a great lunch menu. What can you all suggest around the Cruz Bay area?
We LOVE to cook, and IMHO we cooked the BEST MahiMahi I've ever had last time we were there. So, where's the best place to buy fresh affordable seafood? I've read that the FishTrap and Starfish Market are both options???
We'll be renting a Jeep from Dependable on StT and stopping at CostULess on the way to the car barge, so we could also pick up supplies in StT, though I think the seafood would be better bought on StJ.
Any help you could all give us would be greatly appreciated!