Last night the hubby and I ate at Cruz Bay Prime. I was pleasantly surprised! I really liked the location. I've always been hesitant to go to the Westin for a meal, but I'm glad that we decided to go. I really liked how open and cramped everything was. Even though there was a party and other diners it almost seemed like we were all alone. The service was outstanding. To me, service is what matters most. Our waiter was very attentive, knowledgeable about the menu, and just a nice guy. He is fairly new to island so it was fun for me to talk to him about how he is liking life on St. John.
Ok, for the menu...a bit on the pricey side (but most places are here). One thing that I really liked about the menu is that the "side" items are separate from the entree and they are served family style. We chose two and shared and still had lots of food we had to bring home. Another thing about the menu that was cool is that they had a choice of either Maine or Caribbean (when available) lobster. The menu worked great for us because the husband is a pescetarian and I like a good steak. There were plenty of choices for both of us.
I would definitely go back again!