OK, in another post I talked about "cheap" ways to do St. John. Finally having discovered VRBO plus other suggestions, we are torn between two choices.
1) Sail View - http://www.sailviewstjohn.com
2) Russ' Coral Bay Cottage (not its name, but no real name I can find). http://www.vrbo.com/139712
They are both beautiful and inviting. They are both exerting a strong pull on us, but for slightly different reasons. They both have many OTT fabulous reviews. They are just about the same price for a week in January.
So - does anyone have experience or knowledge with one or the other (or best - BOTH) and maybe give us some differentiators?
I know I shouldn't stress about an island vacation (kind of against the idea, right) - and I know we'll be happy in either place, but any insights or comments you have would be most welcome.