On our 3rd trip to the Carribean and trying to decide where to go - October. Went to Grand Cayman for our 10th anniv., St John for our 15th and now deciding about our 20th destination. We LOVED St John but wonder if we shouldn't try another island since we only make it down about every 5 years. Looking for nice beaches, great snorkeling, great restaurants, and sight seeing options where we can head out on our own or take a day excursion. We aren't too concerned about nightlife. Any insight on T&C or other options would be great. Thanks!