We were set against renting a car due to a incident in Grand Cayman. We had to drive on the left side and were sideswiped but had to pay for the damages. I read that on St. John you also drive on the left? After reading so many posts about needing a car on St. John, we are reconsidering. We aren't going until May but can reserve one now if need be. Can we get it on St. John or do we have to rent on St. Thomas? Who is the best to rent from? There will be six of us. Thanks!