I visited St. John in March of 1998 with my entire family. We enjoyed the unique small charm of the island. Nothing like the hustle and bustle of St. Thomas. We loved having access to beautiful beaches, top notch snorkeling without the crowds. It is now 13 years later and I am getting married and planning a honeymoon. Would you recommend returning to St. John or checking out the BVIs? Our top priorities are seclusion and privacy, relaxation with the option to have some adventure as well. Any other Caribbean suggestions would be great as well!