I'm planning a trip for 6 of my girlfriends next March and we've narrowed down our choice of islands to Eleuthera, Curacao and St. John. All of us are in our late 20s/early 30s and we're all looking for a relaxing vacation and want to rent a villa in order to cook and hang out with each other in the evenings.
St John looks gorgeous although we'd have to drive anytime we wanted to go to the beach. The snorkeling and hiking looks great. In Eleuthera, I'm looking at Sky Beach Club since their 4-bedroom villas look amazing and it's right on the ocean but I'm worried we might get bored after a week. Curacao seems nice in that there's a wide diversity of activities and prices on the island aren't as expensive as St. John or Eleuthera.
Does anyone have thoughts as to which destination might be best for a group of girls?