My husband and I are looking to take one last major vacation before starting a family. We have only been to Mexico, and we were not impressed by the resort scene. We want to be able to explore as we please. We have done research on most of the Caribbean Islands and feel we have narrowed it down to St. John and the Caymans, which I understand are very different islands. We have friends who recently went to the Caymans who swear by it, but St. John is very alluring to me as well. I have read some of the forums on here and they are pretty old so I want to get some new feedback. We are a relatively young couple in our 20's who love to be active, swim, hike, fish, etc. if that helps. Plus, I am always in search for the most beautiful/secluded beaches. Any feedback is appreciated!