First, thanks to everyone for your insights and advice on the forum. The forum and Tripadvisor reviews are my main source of info for planning trips, and we had a great week in St John from June 8-15th. I love going at this time of year, as one often has beaches to herself and no problems with dining out and getting a table.
1) We loved the St. John Inn. Such great attention to detail and friendly owners and staff. We would love to stay there again, and it is a bargain for St. John.
2) Hiking Brown Bay, Rams Head, and Lind Point. We felt like we got our exercise, got fabulous views, and had beaches to ourselves.
3) The Beach Bar: After months of watching the web cams, it was just so fun to be there having a painkiller. Highly recommend to everyone.
4)Snorkeling: Pretty much everywhere but loved Haulover North. Officially the best snorkeling ever, per my husband. I loved Francis, since we saw many turtles, and mangrove snorkeling in Princess Bay was a novel experience.
5)Tourist Trap and Angels Rest: Go. The Tourist Trap drinks and food were fantastic, the view was great, and the bananaquits fun to watch. Angels Rest is a swim up bar in Hansen Bay, and everyone should go to a swim up bar once in their life.
6)Caribbean Night at the Inn of Tamarind Court: We were the only people there and the food was to die for.
We rented a car for a portion of our trip (as advised by the TA forum), and it was absolutely the right choice. Again, thanks everyone, and I hope you all have as wonderful trips as we did.