I know this seems like a weird question because they are two totally different places but I have been doing a little research and have found that the One & Only provides free transportation to Atlantis. We have a 2.5 year old daughter and we have not stayed at either hotel before.
On the one hand, we like the luxury, privacy and quaintness of the One & Only and they seem to have a good kids area from the looks of their website.
On the other hand, the convenience of the proximity of Atlantis to all of their kids features might be more appealing to us. We would be staying at the Reef Tower suites if we stayed at Atlantis.
Does anyone have any insights on this?
P.S. We are going in early December. Is the water cold this time of year? We are from Oklahoma.