So, we decided on Staniel Cay Yacht Club over the Abacos for our 10th anniversary. Thanks to everyone who helped. We are going in late June, and I was frankly amazed that their cottages accommodations are almost completely booked for June (and May , April, July). I thought we'd have our choice six months out - boy, was I wrong!
We were able to get the Orange cottage for three of our four nights. We will be in a larger, non-waterfront Periwinkle cottage on our first night. We pack light, so moving is no big deal for us.
I guess SCYC is popular, huh? Anyway, we are really thrilled and cannot wait. It looks awesome and we can't wait to tool around in our little Whaler.