my hubby and i (in our mid-50's) are in a quandary as to what outer island(s) to visit. we're not high-maintenance. we're big eco-resort/family-run resort/small hotel and inn fans; as long as it's clean, we're happy. depending on if the lodging's an a-i or not will determine how much we'd prefer to spend per night. we don't like to "dress up." he loves to snorkel and can stay in the water all day, and i love a good beach where i can lounge and read. we're in good physical shape and love to hike and explore. we're not fans of nightlife and prefer to wake up early to enjoy as much daytime (and vacation!) as possible. he's a vegetarian, and i'm a pescetarian. we'd love to be able to visit more than one island if "do-able;" if not, no big deal.
any advice/suggestions as to island(s) and accommodation(s) would be greatly appreciated!