We have previously stayed at Finiterre (and loved it). Time to think about a March 2012 return to Eleuthera and I'm doing research on places to stay. There will probably be 2 couples and I'd like to be in the Governor's Harbour/North Palmetto Point area. Here are the houses I've come up with so far. Some are well reviewed already, but I'd love to hear what the TA experts have to say.
Garden of Light (Monticello)
Our desires are to be as close to a beach as possible, and keep our total cost in the $1200-1800 range.