We are planning a trip to Eleuthera. We are thinking about the "Pura Vida" beach front house, although it looks amazing, it may be a wee bit out of our price range. We would like a relatively private house but also would like, if possible, to be able to walk or bike to a local small place to grab a bite, have a beer with the locals or something like that. Last year we traveled to Cat Island, loved it, but we had to drive if we left the property. We are open to other suggestions also re: beach house rentals. We fish, kayak, snorkel, cook, etc. We are a group of 4 adults. We do plan to rent a vehicle at least part of our stay but really do want to be able to walk to access some places.