I have never ever been to an AI before. In recent years my BF and I have cruised and I'm looking for a similar experience. What I enjoy about cruising is that me and my BF have completely different schedules (I work days and he works nights), but the ship is a. safe and b. has different activities and things to do that I don't mind being on my own half of the day. So I'm looking for a resort with a similar feel. I am looking for a nightly show and live music options. I don't want to feel limited on going to restaurants for dinner (no resorts where you can only eat at 3 a la cartes per visit). I'm also really hoping for an "all inclusive" experience, i.e., I don't want to constantly feel like I'm being told there's an upcharges for this restaurant, meal, drink (I don't drink top shelf, smirnoff and bacardi are fine), etc. Ideally I'd like to go to an adults only. We are willing to go off-peak and our budget for the hotel only portion will be 2,000-2,500 for 5-7 nights. Thanks in advance for suggestions!!