I've enjoyed reading this forum for several weeks as we have prepared our trip to the Yucatan!
A couple of quick questions . .
1) If you only had two full days on Isla Mujeres would you still use one of them to visit Isla Contoy? I've heard it is amazing, but there are also lots of other amazing things to see and do in our limited time.
2) I'm staying in Hotel La Joya on the South end of the island, I think it looks amazing and fun, but I am kind of nervous about the cost of getting to and from town. We plan on renting a cart one day, but do you know approximate taxi fares to the other end of the island, or to and from the ferry pier? Do you think the pros of such a great little hotel outweigh the cons of having to pay extra for transport on a pretty walkable island? My other choice was Posada Del Mar. I'm just all torn up inside about it : )