We've been back for a couple of weeks now, but I wanted to say an enormous thank you for all the kind advice and input we had over the past 6 months planning our trip. Everything was perfect- our activities, our hotel, restaurants. I feared having been there before this trip would be a let down, but honestly, it was probably the most wonderful trip out of several my husband and I have done together. Every day one of us looks at the other and says "I want to go away again". :)
So THANK YOU everyone and to all the helpful hometown folk - I hope you all delight in the amazing place you call home.
I'll post our schedule below for the folks looking for ideas. :)