This seems to be a popular topic....which island is best value when comparing luxury, food and snorkelling. My fiance and I facing this delimma as to which island would be best suited to elope on, have a romantic honeymoon, enjoy wonderful food and snorkel. We are looking at going in October 2009. Lizard is most expensive when adding on the transfer flights and wedding package ~ $4000 more than Orpheus for 5 nights, whilst Bedarra sits in the middle ~$2000 more expensive than Orpheus. Can anyone help us decide as ~$4000 difference is quite significant?