Looking to plan one really nice meal during our honeymoon on Kauai -- have eaten at Beach House and really liked it ... I see lots of recs on here for Tidepools, and was just looking at the menu.
I was leaning towards Tidepools for the setting and the fact that I hadn't been there, but the menu -- or at least the one posted online -- seems fairly standard and unexciting.
So ... why do you prefer one of these places over the other? Or, is there somewhere else you'd recommend? What about Plantation Gardens?