My husband and I have been to Kauai 5 times (Poipu) and absolutely love it! We enjoy snorkeling, hitting the remote beaches (we like anything that's off-the-beaten-path) as well as moderate hiking. We've travelled the island from the south end to the north end and everything in between and always find something new to discover. We're not into large crowds or fancy dinners - we pack the cooler for the day and we're gone for most of it! We enjoy comfortable and clean accommodations and at least an ocean-view from our lanai. We feel we've been so spoiled by Kauai that nothing else will compare but we've heard great things about Maui and think we'd like to give it a try. For those of you that have been to both islands - please give me your feed-back. Would we be disappointed if we chose Maui considering all the things I mentioned previously? Any recommendations on where to stay would be greatly appreciated. Thank-you in advance!!