Whichever is nearest. I don’t like to end an expensive meal with a long drive or a large Taxi/ Uber/ Lyft fee
I agree with Ducksdelux - both very good places, but I don't think I'd drive an extra 60 minutes for one vs. the other
For me, it would hinge on where I was staying.
While I have enjoyed both, I would not drive almost across the Island, for either, but would book whichever was closest to me.
Both are very good.
Closest one to you