Thanks for confirming Jet72's recommendation of the Anaco Bay Inn (Re: luaulady's San Juan Motel thread in the Anacortes forum--rather than hijack that one further, I started this new thread). The rates were so reasonable at the Anaco Bay, I was a little unsure if I had the right place! The Calico Cupboard is definitely our breakfast plan--I doubt the continental breakfast that comes with the room can compare, although including breakfast is another point for the Anaco Bay Inn.
I really hope we'll get a chance to walk the loop in WA park as you mentioned. It sounds like such a beautiful place. We're also hoping to get over to Guemes for an hour or so as Jet suggested. We'd like to try Anderson's General Store for lunch, but we also wanted to eat at The Chocolate Factory. Too many choices! We're going to have to walk all the way back to Florida to get rid of the diet damage from this trip!
Thanks to both you and Jet72 for your helpful advice about Anacortes. I feel so much better prepared, especially since it's such a short visit. I'm sure we'll be back!