My boyfriend and I are planning a trip to Key West this summer and I had a couple of questions. I have found 2 fairly cheap hotels that we are trying to decide between, but they are at different ends of the island, one is at 1125 Duval Street and the other Roosevelt Blvd. The one on Roosevelt seems more out of the way, but the one on Duval doesn't appear to be near where the "action" is either (I guess it is more towards the southern part of the island). Would either be a better choice? I was also wondering if we should plan on renting a car or not? I realize the island is small, but I didn't know how much transportation costs and how much walking we would/could actually do. Any suggestions or comments would be appreciated. Thanks!