So we are having our wedding in September of 2015 at Smathers Beach in Key West. We do not want a reception, instead we'd just like to have a nice dinner with the people who came for our wedding (We live in Michigan). I have looked at a lot of places but have no idea which direction to go in. Still don't know exact number of people we will have since we havent sent out the invites but probably in the ball park of 35 people. My first pick was Hot Tin Roof, but they said we'd have to pay a site fee of $1500...for nothing basically. Which did not sit well with me. Second choice was A and B Lobster house but when I contacted them they said they are closed during the months of September/October. Also considering Lattitudes but was just a little bit pricier than we were looking for at $125/plate, we were looking around $85/plate. Going to be checking into The Pier House and The Commodore. Any suggestions, ideas? Please help!!