What started out as a trip for my husband and I, for his 40th birthday, has now turned into a surprise party for him! His brothers and wives and some friends are all coming down as well, he just doesn't know it yet. We are going down in the first week of May and staying at the Southernmost. Not having ever been to the Keys before, I'm not sure of where to try to plan a surprise party! Money is an issue, and I'm not entirely certain how many people will be attending, which makes it that much more difficult to plan. If I had to estimate, I'd say probably 15 - 20 people, and I'd like to spend less than $20pp, if possible! I was thinking of possibly a sunset cruise, poolside at the Southernmost (not sure of cost) or drinks & apps at one of the landmark bars (Capt Tonys, Sloppy Joes, etc.) Anyone have suggestions for me? Thanks!!