We are travelling to Sanibel in Sept (20-22) after our cruise. Our kids are 13 & 16. I went to Sanibel as a teen & wanted husband & kids to see the island. I had our choices narrowed down to Sanibel Inn, West Wind Inn, Waterside Inn, or Holiday Inn. Then I found Shalimar & Beachview cottages. Everything seems to get such mixed reviews. Holiday Inn is by far the most reasonable ($125/night) & Waterside & West Wind the most expensive. We don't need anything fancy but would like to be gulf front/gulf view. I would appreciate any pros/cons to the above places. Thanks in advance for your thoughts.