I posted before asking for general guidance, now that I've read a bit more, I think I've at least narrowed down what we are looking for. :)
We will be in Sanibel in the middle of May----can't wait!! I'm a huge beachlover, and this will be our kids first trip to the ocean! (5 and 8 years old). We've never been to Sanibel. Here is what we are hoping for
-something beach front with a pool
-relatively close to activities, but this is not essential, we'd drive a bit if we found a good place to stay!
-someone who will accept at 5-6 night stay.
-something really nice....we don't travel much, so we want this to be really special.
-a kitchenette so we could cook in b-fast/lunch.
Thanks so much for your guidance and info!