We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Avoid VRBO.com/85379 and its Unethical Agent

New York, NY
1 post
Save Topic
Avoid VRBO.com/85379 and its Unethical Agent

Our week in the village of Stonington on Deer Isle was ruined by the appalling treatment we received from Cathy Pierce McGuire and her company Pierce Property Management (aka Seaside Rentals www.seasiderentalsmaine.com), PO Box 38, Sunset, Maine 04683. We paid more than $2000 upfront for a one-week rental of Bay View House at 35 Bayview Street in Stonington, Maine via VRBO.com/85379. We could have tolerated the fact that much of the house smelled strongly of mold; that the unrenovated first floor was home to numerous bugs and spiders; that the puddle-filled basement was like a scene from a horror movie; and that this rental was adjacent to a loud and unsightly lobster business. By themselves, these issues would not have been nearly enough to ruin our vacation or compel us to call the agent, let alone write a negative report. As frequent vacation-home renters, we can adapt to a variety of circumstances and "surprises" not mentioned in the listing advertisement. But we do expect the things listed to be present, and that we will be treated honestly and professionally by the people we do business with. The VRBO ad for this property listed a "Dishwasher" among its amenities. The fact that the house didn't have one was a misrepresentation that annoyed us a lot. This was an amenity which we had paid for and which mattered to us. Much worse, however, was the fact that after we complained by voicemail to Cathy Pierce McGuire, instead of calling us back and apologizing, she altered the listing and lied about doing so. Rather than communicating with us about our concerns, Cathy Pierce McGuire and her company resorted to deception. As soon as we left her a first voicemail message mentioning the Dishwasher problem, she deleted the item "Dishwasher" from the list of amenities on her VRBO page and from that point on, everyone associated with the company attempted to conceal and/or lie that this change had been made or that the word "Dishwasher" had ever appeared on the VRBO page. On the two occasions when anyone associated with Pierce Property Management actually answered the phone (these people were not even office staff but a housekeeper and a lobsterman; and we don't think there actually is an office staff) we were promised swift return phone calls from Cathy Pierce. These never came. Our request for an apology or explanation about this situation resulted in us being treated in an insulting and offensive manner, by the housekeeper mentioned above (who's also Cathy Pierce's mother, we later found out) who goaded us with, "Well, I hope you have a printout because it doesn't say dishwasher now!" To add insult to injury, when we finally heard from Cathy Pierce McGuire -- 10-days after our initial complaint on a 7-day rental -- it was not to apologize or explain but to insult us and continue the lies. Pierce Property Management (aka Seaside Rentals) of Sunset, Maine is not a company you should do business with. Cathy Pierce McGuire also has other listings on VRBO, including VRBO.com/54893 and VRBO.com/85783. She also uses the names Cathy P. McGuire and Cathy McGuire, uses the phone numbers 207-348-6462 and 207-348-2349 and the e-mail address cathyre@midmaine.com. We are experienced travelers who have had many good experiences with VRBO and other vacation rentals and have never before written a complaint. We just do not like being lied to and treated badly. It's a shame we had this experience because the renovated half of the house was acceptable, the view was nice from the upstairs balcony and the town of Stonington has many charming shops and restaurants. We only wish we could have enjoyed them more. We wrote this comment as a public service, hoping it will help other travelers make a better choice than we did in Stonington.

Level Contributor
57 posts
15 reviews
Save Reply
1. Re: Avoid VRBO.com/85379 and its Unethical Agent

Thanks for the heads-up. We use VRBO often and have never had a problem. Going to Maine at the end of Sept for a week in a VRBO cabin as a matter of fact. We've had good luck so far and hope our maine trip will be as good as others.


2. Re: Avoid VRBO.com/85379 and its Unethical Agent

-:- Message from TripAdvisor staff -:-

This topic has been closed to new posts due to inactivity. We hope you'll join the conversation by posting to an open topic or starting a new one.

To review the TripAdvisor Forums Posting Guidelines, please follow this link: http://www.tripadvisor.com/pages/forums_posting_guidelines.html

We remove posts that do not follow our posting guidelines, and we reserve the right to remove any post for any reason.

Removed on: 14 March 2010, 06:19
Get answers to your questions about Deer Isle