Four Indiana rural living adults are traveling to Bushkill, PA. We are spending 1 day in New York City and seeing a Broadway play at the end of the day. Problem: How do we get from Bushkill, PA comfortably - and safely. None of us have experience driving in large metropolitan cities and I can't find any bus schedules that run after midnight. It was recommended to park at either Secaucus or Willowbrook Mall and take the bus but it doesn't appear there are any buses to take back to either area until 3 a.m. Any solutions that don't include driving into NYC (which would mean arguing the entire way because of the tension of not knowing how to get anywhere). Remember, we have no experience with subways, mass transit, etc. Was hoping to be able to take a cab from some easy location but can't find anyway to contact any cab without first knowing what cab I need. Thanks.