We have tried almost every restaurant on the island over the years with the exception of AJ's and The Sea shell Cafe. Afraid to try the Sea Shell Cafe after reading some really bad reviews about the service. Seen rave reviews for Bill's and while its on our list to visit again, I'm just curious which place do you think has the best seafood? We aren't big fish eaters but prefer shrimp, crab cakes, scallops etc. Any suggestions? Thanks!