Trying to make up our minds between the two! Group of 6: 3 daughters, elderly mom-86, 2 husbands, all 50+. Found a historic charmer to rent on Lost lake and a brand new home on Eagle Lake. We want the best of both worlds..get away from it all, but still have places to go when we start getting cabin fever. Also, coming from Milwaukee area, is it that much further to Saint Germain? Any pros or cons of each area would be great! Thanks!