My wife and I just decided to take a trip to NYC for our upcoming 40th anniversary. Wow, I'm old! Anyway, our plan is to take in a broadway show on Saturday night while there and then on Sunday, go to a nice restaurant before retuning home Monday am. Our trip is in mid September.
So a 2 part question:
1). We want to find an "interesting" restaurant around the theater district. By interesting, good food with interesting surroundings/ambiance. Doesn't have to be "fancy", casual fare is fine. We're typically "simple" folk.
2). A nice restaurant that can be accessed by subway, easily, from the Times Square section. We stay at the Muse which is a block from TS.