We've vacationed several times on Captiva, but this time we need a much larger rental for a family reunion (which is WAY too expensive on Captiva). We love the island feel on Captiva, walking sandy lanes from the village to the beach, and the all-over "vibe". Do you think we will like Anna Maria Island? We've stayed on Sanibel as well and didn't like it as well (more crowded, lots of traffic on Periwinkle, etc.). Thanks for your thoughts!