I'm debating between these 2 hotels when staying for 2 nights in Pienza. Both are close to the historical center, have free parking and have great reviews. Both are reasonably priced. While Hotel La Valle have better views, the rooms look quite bare and I'm not sure how comfortable the beds are. Arca di Pienza rooms look really lovely and they have private terraces, but I saw one review that they may be noisy due to proximity to the road.
Would greatly appreciate the advise.