Casa Amistad is in the center of Isabel Segunda (the larger of the two towns on the island.) It is run by Owen, David and Dan (all mid-westerners) and they do a superb job in offering the most comfortable stay you could hope for and all for very reasonable prices. From the spacious common kitchen to the pristine pool, they keep the place in a tip top spotless condition. There's a tv room and excellent wifi too (streamed HBO fine) too.
Having stayed at Amistad over 6 times now, I can honestly say these guys go far, far out of their way to make you feel at home. They will arm you with all the information you might need to find the best beach (Plata), bar (Al's at sunset) or restaurant (it's a toss up). In short, if you are like us and want to find a warm, friendly, inviting place that won't bust your budget, it is right here.More