There are two Alexander's restaurant locations- one above Bon Appetite and one next door to the Stone at the waterfront in Simpson Bay Resort. The Simpson Bay resort and Villas advertise weekly BBQ and pasta specials at the waterfront location, which is usually otherwise not open for dinner. The waterfront site is open for breakfast and lunch, and although we were told by the resort the location up the hill was open for dinner only, it may be open for all 3 mealtimes. Reading the other reviews, they must all be referring to the uphill location. We went to The waterfront site for the advertised pasta night, and it was the worst dining experience I have ever had on the Island. Many folks came and sat, but left without ordering. Our food was cold, the bread was day-old, the service was lackadaisical and unapologetic. I'm not sure why, but on another occasion we decided to see how their breakfast was, but after we sat for a while, I asked the server if she came to the table or should we order at the kitchen - she said she served the tables, but after waiting a while longer without being approached, we left.
If you wish to try this restaurant, stay away from the waterfront location.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.