We went to the Lobster Pot in 2006 and had a horrible experience. The food was okay but the staff was extremely rude. They were not busy at all and were too interested in chatting to take care of customers. It took several hours to get the food which was okay.
Due to this horrific experience we had not been back until last week despite regular travel to Cayman (four times to in the last year). We decided we would give it another shot while dining with friends who live on island. The staff was courteous and the food fairly good. My husband and I shared an entrée which was $52 CI which is about $65 US; double the cost of most other menu items. We advised that we did not want a baked potato and asked if we could sub plantains. They brought BOTH of us baked potatoes, which we said we did not want and the plantains as a side. We were with friends and did not carefully inspect the bill which normally I do. Upon arrival back at our villa, I found a $10 CI split charge and a $5 CI charge for plantains which is about $18.75 US. They did not advise us of any split fee nor did they say we would be charged when we asked for plantains IN LIEU OF the potato, which we asked them not to give us. I did not want nor eat the potato. Our bill for the shared single entrée was more than that of our friends who had two entrees. We will be back in Cayman in two months and WILL NOT return then or ever.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.