I had come here (Tripadvisor) to read about Caneel Bay Resort before we booked our honeymoon. Our experience at Turtle Bay Estate in NO WAY matched the positive experiences I've read. I was prepared for the high dollar prices and was willing to pay "since it was our honemoon", but we never felt we got what we paid for at ANY of the restaurants at Caneel Bay Resort. (The Sugar Mill was the worst.) When guest gathered to meet/visit at tea time, ferry ride, etc., we would hear echo the same disappointment. I'm not suggesting the food was THAT bad, but we did not get what we paid for. We want to return to Caneel Bay Resort, but next time we will venture "off campus" for dinner. On a positive note, 4pm tea at Turtle Bay Estate was delightful...don't miss it!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.