After reading the reviews, husband and I were very excited to try Tony's pizza.
We got the antipasto sampler (cant remember the name) and the Tony's Deluxe Pizza (the supposed best-seller). What a disappointment! While the meats and cheeses on the antipasti plate were good and fresh, the pizza was nothing like real italian pizza. I have been to Italy several times, as well as NYC, and I know what real italian pizza tastes like. The dough was nowhere near that awesome taste of bread, it was dry and there wasn't enough cheese, and the pizza istelf was way overcooked. The staff is super friendly and the place feels very authentic, but we left very, very disappointed after so many great promises.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.