We decided on the Montague River Cottages for the location. We loved that they are right on the Confederation Trail as we are bikers. When we got there, note on door said to call one of two numbers for service. We had no problem with this, even though we have pay as you go cell phone. We reached Mark who was there within 5 minutes to check us in. Cottage had a bit of a musty smell when we went in but once we were in and turned the heat on (it was cool out) the smell went away. For rest of weekend, we had windows opened as it had warmed up and we had no issue. Cottages clean and everything you needed in them. We had taken a couple of things with us from our kitchen but they were supplied so ours were not used. When I initially sat on the bed I thought "oh-oh, quite hard" but actually had no problems with sleep, even sleeping in our second morning. Absolutely beautiful location right on the Montague River and very well kept grounds. Very central location in Eastern PEI, not far to anywhere. Only a couple of minor drawbacks - first not the best sound proofing - could hear the neighbours walking, closing doors (even with windows closed), but they are older cottages which have been updated. I would think would cost $$$ to better sound proof. Second the whole toilet paper issue - it was only two of us in our cottage but I would think if more than two this would be an issue. Not sure how much this saves the management, but I would think not much. The soap issue is a non issue for us as we always bring our own with us. Third, when we checked in our garbage/compost had not been cleaned from previous occupant and we found a dirty towel hanging on back of bedroom door. Not a big issue for us, but it could be for others. My only issue with it was previous occupant had put non-compost in the compost and I was not digging it out :) Overall it was a great place to stay and for sure we would have no hesitation staying again. Compared to a cottage we had stayed in at Brackley the long May weekend - by far better ( I should write a review on that horror story sometime) - and better value - more expensive for the Brackley one bedroom than the two bedroom we stayed in here.